AVERAKS/Guides/New site or fix the old one
Do I need a new website or can mine be fixed?
The short answer
Fix it if the foundations are sound and the problems are on the surface: wording, photos, a broken form. Rebuild it if the problems are structural: it is slow, it breaks on phones, nobody can update it, or it was built on a template that fights every change.
Signs it can be fixed
- It loads quickly and works properly on a phone
- You can log in and change things yourself, or someone you trust can
- The layout is fine but the words and photos are out of date
- One or two things are broken, such as a form or a map
In these cases a tidy up is honest work and a rebuild would be money spent for its own sake.
Signs it needs rebuilding
- It takes more than a few seconds to load on mobile data
- It was built by someone who has disappeared, and nobody has the logins
- Every change breaks something else
- It looks like a hundred other sites because it is the same template
- It does not show up on Google for your own business name
- You are embarrassed to send people to it
That last one counts. If you avoid giving out your web address, the site is costing you work.
The question that settles it
Ask what the site needs to do in the next two years. If the answer is "the same, but tidier", fix it. If the business has changed, with new services, online booking, a store or a different kind of customer, patching an old structure usually costs more over time than starting clean. Voltage Energy came to us with an old site full of missing buttons and bugs. That one was a rebuild, and it is on our work page.
What you keep either way
Your domain, your Google Business Profile, your reviews and your photos all carry over. A rebuild done properly also redirects every old address to its new one so Google does not lose track of you.